About Us.

Our Restaurant Is A Collective Of Amazing People Striving To Build Delightful Italian Cuisine.

Established in 1991 starting as a small pizzeria with merely 12 seats surrounding four handmade tables, Nicky’s Firehouse maintained the family values and hometown integrity to become a Madison landmark. After the first renovation in 1995, seating grew to 40. Staying true to his roots, Nick Lardieri invested every bit of time and energy into establishing the Firehouse brand, making the name synonymous with great pizza, great food, and a welcoming family environment. The dynamic design, along with friendly employees and delicious food makes Nicky’s Firehouse the perfect go-to spot in the area

New Owners

New owners Joseph and Amanda Peluso are continuing to carry on the traditions that the Firehouse was built on. Joseph has over 20 years experience in the hospitality industry as a chef, owner and manager. They are both so excited to bring new dishes and experiences to Madison for years to come. Welcome to our new home!!


Signature Dishes

Restaurant Amenities

Free WiFi

Online Ordering



"My second visit and it was delicious. The pizza was outstanding. The service impeccable. The atmosphere perfect."
- Lisa Karoon

Recommended By